Montana Wines

Montana are the goliath of New Zealand wines. They are the country's biggest producer and exporter. As I am currently in New Zealand and drinking a fair bit of the stuff, (well it would be rude and uncultural not to). I was wondering if the design on their bottles and other public literature matches the values I can surmise from their website. If we take a look at the site we see that there is a strong natural theme in the imagery used. On there front page they state their mission "we work hard to deftly coax out all the nuances that nature offers us, so that the truly vibrant taste of Montana wines can shine through".The power of nature plus the craft of the wine maker equals great wine... sounds simple but is very powerful. This to some degree is suggested on the website but it would seem in a rather superficial way. The shots of the vines are somewhat generic, how exactly do you "coax out nuances of nature" and what are they? We learn more when the different branded varieties are described. "The cool, sunny climate, rugged topography and geologically young soils combine to produce some of the world’s most distinctive wine" Still the explanations are vague and do not bring the relationship of winemaker and nature to life. And if we weren't sure about the quality of the wine there is good lengthy description of the production methods, full of tradition and care. A good proportion of the site is given over to the promotion of New Zealand and it's attraction to the tourist. So mixed messages coming from the site. How do the bottles measure up to that core statement.



The logo is somewhat monolithic in its execution. The mountains pictured are foreboding rather than inviting. They say little of the nuances of nature that produce the vibrant wine inside. Come to that there is little to communicate the vibrancy of the product inside. I would judge that this wine was dependable and of good quality but vibrant? I don't think so.


In short I think that Montana is suffering somewhat of an identity crisis. The mantle of being NZ's biggest wine, seems to weigh heavy on its shoulders. There is not enough vibrancy inspired through nature and it looks like the craftsman has been replaced by a big shiny metal machine.



To further confuse the matter their new series of premium quality wines move further away from the nature and craft message. The idea behind this range is simple and powerful. The wines are reflective of the area they come from, representative of the different natural elements that their geography provides. They are crafted by artisans.The letters on this series although visually striking communicate little of this. I like their simplicity and the idea of a simple logo that represents the different areas but couldn't that work harder?







These coffees by Robert Harris sucessfully communicate that they are created by craftsmen inspired by and in tune with nature. And to boot they have a strong New Zealand identity and a vibrant appeal.